AC Installation Español
How to Fix a Running Toilet
Book Now
Book Now
Blog 03/14/23

How to Fix a Running Toilet

If  your toilet won’t stop running, you will unfortunately end up with a larger water bill than expected. However, it’s easy to learn how to fix a running toilet and take care of the situation quickly. This is one project that doesn’t require any plumbing experience. All you need are a few simple tools and an hour of free time to stop your toilet from running, and have it functioning correctly.

It’s a good idea to fix a running toilet as soon as you notice the problem. A toilet that keeps running can waste hundreds of gallons of water each day and will cause an increased water bill. The good news is that the steps for fixing a running toilet are usually pretty simple.

Gather the Needed Tools and Parts

The first step is to take the lid off the tank to see where the problem lies. The issue can be caused by a leaking flapper or a fill valve that has gone bad. If the overflow pipe is at the wrong height, it can prevent the flapper from working correctly.

You’ll need some pliers and a hacksaw. You may also need to buy a new fill valve or flapper, available at your local hardware store.

Why Does My Toilet Keep Running?

There are a few reasons a toilet won’t stop running. All of them are fairly easy fixes once you determine the cause, and we’ll explain how to fix a running toilet now.

When the Flapper is the Problem

In order to find out which part is causing the water to continue flowing, the first thing to do is jiggle the handle. If the water shuts off, it could mean the chain that connects the handle to the flapper is too long. Use your pliers to readjust and shorten the chain. If the chain is too short, it won’t allow the flapper to close. You may need to add a link to the chain so that the flapper will fit down and seal completely.

If this doesn't resolve the problem, the next step is to check the flapper itself. The flapper is a round rubber piece that opens when you flush and closes when the tank is full. Push down on the top of the flapper and see if the water stops running in. If this step fixes the issue, you’ll need to replace the flapper because it isn’t sealing properly.

Before replacing the flapper to fix a running toilet, you will want to inspect the seal. The flapper can be cleaned in warm soapy water to remove any mineral buildup. This is especially important if you live in a hard water area like San Diego. Vinegar is another good cleansing product to remove hardened minerals. Once the flapper is clean, you can replace it and see if it works correctly. If not, the only option is to replace it.

Before replacing the flapper, you will need to shut off the water to the tank. The water supply valve is usually under the toilet. If you can’t locate it, turn off the main water supply.

Flush the toilet. This will empty most of the water out of the tank. Unhook the flapper from the tank. Install the new flapper according to the package instructions. When you hook the chain onto the flush lever arm, make sure to leave just a little slack when the flapper is closed to allow it to seal properly. Otherwise, you’ll end up with the same issue of a toilet that keeps running after a flush.

A Leaking Fill Valve

Another problem with a toilet that won’t stop running might be the fill valve. When you flush the toilet, look for a leak around the fill valve. Lift up on the float arm while water runs into the tank. Notice if the water stops and adjust the arm to allow the tank to stop filling when the water reaches about half an inch from the top.

If the fill valve is still leaking after the adjustment, it will need to be replaced. With this repair, you'll need to shut off the water, flush the toilet, and dip or sponge out any remaining water. Place a bucket under the tank to catch any leftover water that may drip out once the fill valve has been removed. The washer and nut are often made of plastic in newer toilets. Disconnect the water supply line and remove the locknut on the fill valve. Remove the fill valve from the tank.

Put the new valve into the tank and tighten the locknut. Make sure to secure it tightly to prevent leaks. The overflow pipe may need to be shortened to the critical level mark with a hacksaw. The new fill tube must be attached to the fill valve nipple with the other end attached to an angle adapter. Clip the adapter to the overflow pipe and attach the flapper chain to the lever arm. Once you turn on the water, test the toilet by flushing it. Adjust the water level by turning the screw on the fill valve. This screw changes the height of the float.

One of these DIY repairs will usually fix a toilet that constantly runs. If you have problems with the repair, questions on how to fix a running toilet, or find other issues with your toilet or tank, contact Bill Howe. Our plumbers are experienced in all kinds of home and commercial plumbing repairs and can ensure your toilet is working correctly. 

We are experienced in residential plumbing and can tackle all necessary repairs and replacements. We diagnose the issue and replace any worn-out parts to stop the toilet from running. We also handle wastewater systems and issues. When you need help, trust Bill Howe, because we know Howe!


Leave a Reply

Related Posts

how to fix a running toilet

How to Fix a Running Toilet

If  your toilet won’t stop running, you will unfortunately end up with a larger water bill than expected. However, it’s easy to learn how to fix a running toilet and take care of the...

2 weeks ago Share Icon
Read More

What David says about us

Service for new garbage disposal. My ancient garbage disposal quit working, went online to get Bill Howe’s number, immediately received and accepted chat to describe my needs. Prompt call back to schedule an appointment, service tech Allen was out same morning, which was important to fit my work schedule. Job estimate was clear, work done fully to my expectations, area left clean, and price was very fair.
I was not surprised — I have used Bill Howe plumbers for several other tasks in the past. I have always found their staff to be helpful, attentive, and the plumbers very courteous and capable.

January 2020


What Michelle says about us

I have been using Bill Howe since the late 1980’s, their service has always been excellent, plumbing, heating and restoration. I am most impressed by the integrity of their employees, not only do they know their work/skill, they do not waste time, they are so efficient, they are so helpful and they are a true “service”!

February 2020


What Mira says about us

Bill Howe never fails us! We had a drain overflow, and Scott came (on a Saturday) to look at it and offer solution. He was punctual, professional, and extremely helpful. I should also praise the main office for always being helpful and always finding solutions. Very grateful to have you in San Diego!

February 2020

Restoration & Flood

What Ed Gohlich says about us

Cory was our technician on this job. We had a time sensitive repair issue and Bill Howe understood and assisted with getting the job done quickly.
Cory was on time to start the job and finished it quickly. Upon his leaving our home he’s was courteous, very knowledgeable, explaining what the problem was and how he fixed it. Very good communication and this is the way it’s has always been when we use Bill Howe plumbing.
Great company to work with.
Thanks Cory.

August 2019

Heating & Cooling

What Eric says about us

I had a shower that would not drain. The employee arrived on time and fixed the problem quickly and effectively at a very fair price. I was very happy with everything. Thank you and I highly recommend your plumbing service.

January 2019


What Bridgett says about us

I am extremely happy with the service we received from Bill Howe Plumbing. We were given an incorrect diagnosis of our main sewer line from another vendor, but Bill Howe’s servicemen came out for a second opinion, correctly diagnosed our problem and resolved our back up issues. We will continue to use Bill Howe for all our future plumbing needs!

Thank you Bill Howe Plumbing.

July 2019